Skip to content
Neet Bulletin

Neet Bulletin

  • Ei pelkästään suuret bonukset, vaan myös mobiilipelien jännitys on huipussaan, kun avaat Pistolo-sovelluksen älypuhelimellasi ja nautit suoratoiston live-jakajista.

  • Home
  • Course
    • MBBS
    • BAMS
    • BDS
    • BHMS
    • BUMS
    • Nursing
      • ANM
      • GNM
      • B.Sc Nursing
    • Pharmacy
  • Admission
    • Allen Admission
    • BDS-Admission
    • BAMS Admission
    • UG
    • PG
    • PHD
  • Counselling
    • Neet UG
    • Ayush
  • News
  • Campus News
  • Toggle search form
  • NEET-PG 2025 Cut-Off Reduction:
    Understanding the Alarming NEET PG Cut-offs: A Focus on Gynaecology and Orthopaedics Medical Exams
  • Kerala Assembly
    Kerala Assembly’s Resolution to Reform National Entrance Exam System and NEET Concerns Education Policies
  • NEET UG 2025
    NEET UG 2025 Exam: अगले साल कई फेज में आयोजित हो सकती है नीट यूजी परीक्षा, नोटिफिकेशन जल्द होगा जारी Education
  • Telangana NEET UG 2024
    Telangana NEET UG 2024 Phase 1 Seat Allotment Results Out: Check Here! Education
  • A one-day anti-drug awareness camp was organized at Ras Bihari Bose Subharti University Dehradoon
  • CBSE Assessments
    Understanding the CBSE CTET 2026 Answer Key and How to Raise Objections Education
  • NEET UG 2025
    NEET UG Result 2024: How to Check Merit List and Key Details Education
  • CBSE
    Understanding the CBSE Class 12 Supplementary Result 2026 Education
MBBS admissions

‘Both hands intact’ rule for MBBS admissions ableist: SC

Posted on February 22, 2025 By neet bulletin No Comments on ‘Both hands intact’ rule for MBBS admissions ableist: SC

MBBS admissions : The Supreme Court strongly criticised the National Medical Commission’s (NMC) regulations requiring candidates to have “both hands intact” to qualify for medical education.

The Supreme Court on Friday strongly criticised the National Medical Commission’s (NMC) regulations requiring candidates to have “both hands intact” to qualify for medical education, calling it a glorification of “ableism” that contradicts the principles of reasonable accommodation and inclusivity enshrined in the law.

“It indicates a classification which is overbroad and glorifies ableism. It propagates that persons with typical abilities and with faculties similar to what the majority may have or somehow superior. This is precisely what the directive principles of state policy, the United Nations Convention and the RPwD (Rights of Persons with Disabilities) Act, abhor,” said a bench of justices Bhushan R Gavai and KV Viswanathan.

The court held that barring a candidate at the threshold solely based on physical disability violates constitutional guarantees and international conventions on the rights of persons with disabilities. The judgment stressed that the NMC stipulation of “both hands intact with intact sensations, sufficient strength and range of motion” unjustly bars individuals with upper limb disabilities from pursuing medical education, despite their capability to perform as competent doctors with reasonable accommodations.

The judgment came as the court ruled in favour of an aspiring doctor with a 58% disability, directing his admission to an MBBS course while calling upon NMC to revise its outdated guidelines.

The case concerned a petitioner whose admission to a medical college was denied based on NMC’s 2019 guidelines, which mandate that candidates must have both hands intact, with sufficient strength and range of motion. The petitioner, who secured a high rank in the NEET-UG 2024 exam under the PwD (OBC) category, was deemed ineligible by the disability assessment board despite his ability to perform essential clinical functions.

The top court rejected this reasoning, noting that the assessment panel failed to conduct a proper functional evaluation and was “shackled” by the rigid rule of “both hands intact”. The court found that such an exclusionary requirement lacked legal sanctity and was inconsistent with the Rights of Persons with Disabilities (RPwD) Act, 2016, which emphasises functional assessment rather than blanket disqualifications.

The court referred to its own previous rulings, including two October 2024 judgments in the cases of Omkar Ramchandra Gond and Om Rathod, where it mandated the revision of medical education guidelines to align with constitutional and statutory rights of disabled persons.

Observing that the “both hands intact” requirement is an outdated and discriminatory classification, the bench stated: “A prescription such as ‘both hands intact’ reeks of ableism and has no place in a statutory regulation. It denudes the rights guaranteed under the Constitution and makes a mockery of the principle of reasonable accommodation.”

The bench emphasised that modern medicine and assistive technology enable persons with disabilities to perform medical duties competently and that presuming incompetence at the threshold is unfair. Instead, the court suggested allowing candidates to complete MBBS and then decide their specialisation based on their functional abilities.

0Shares
Blog, Education, Neet Tags:MBBS admissions

Post navigation

Previous Post: Revolutionizing Education: CBSE to Allow Double Attempts for Class 10 Board Exams and Introduce a Global Curriculum
Next Post: Meet NEET topper who scored 715 marks out of 720, got 99.99 percentile in first attempt, MS Dhoni, is his…

Related Posts

  • CBSE-dual-board-exam-2026
    CBSE Dual Board Exam for Class 10 in February 2026 Education
  • CBSE Class 10 French
    CBSE Admit Cards 2026: Release Date and Download Guide Education
  • NEET
    NEET Paper Leak: Centre Assures Supreme Court It Is Going ‘Ten Extra Miles’ for Students Education
  • NEET UG 2025
    Important Details on NEET UG 2025 Application Form Release Exams and Admissions
  • NEET MDS 2026
    NEET UG 2026 Exam City Intimation Slip Released: Check Your Allotted City Here Education
  • AIIMS Secures 127th Global Rank in QS 2024 Medicine Subject Rankings: A Testament to Excellence in Medical Education and Research Education

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

READ MORE
Loading
Live Cricket Scores

  • NEET UG 2024 Answer Key
    CBSE Class 10 Social Science Answer Key 2024 Set 2 with Question Paper PDF Board Exam 2025
  • Supreme Court
    NEET-UG 2024 Supreme Court Hearing Live Updates: SC Resumes Hearing; Seeks Clarity on Exam Centre Change Education News
  • MCC Registration Link
    NEET UG Counselling 2025 Begins: MCC Registration Link, MBBS Seat Matrix, and Cut-off Details Education
  • CBSE Cancels Class 10 Exams
    CBSE Cancels Class 10 Exams and Reschedules Class 12 Board Exams in the Middle East: What You Need to Know Education Updates
  • NEET UG Paper
    My Journey Through the NEET UG Paper: A Personal Experience at VMMC Education
  • CBSE Class 10th Mathematics Standard And Mathematics Basic Board Exam Concludes; Check Paper Analysis By Experts Board Exam 2025
  • The Impact of Limiting Batch Size in New Medical Colleges on Medical Education and Infrastructure Education
  • Round 1
    NEET PG 2026 Round 1 Provisional Allotment: How to Check Your Result and What to Do Next Medical Education

Copyright © 2026 Neet Bulletin.

Powered by PressBook News WordPress theme